Microgrids for the developed world?

In places like India where the electric grid needs massive updating to reach its users and provide them with adequate power, microgrids, which are loosely defined as a systems of distributed power resources that can parallel or island from the grid, are proving an attractive alternative. But it’s not just the developing world where many are asking whether microgrids could have value.

Part of what is driving interest in microgrids in the developed world is concern about the reliability of the grid. In a recent Pike Research webinar, Horizon Energy Group CEO Steve Pullins cited data showing that in the U.S. the average outage duration is 120 minutes and getting worse. This compares to the 10 minute average in the industrialized world. Perhaps more distressing for utilities is that capital asset utilization rates are around 45 percent, meaning for the amount of money being deployed on power generation and distribution, a relatively low portion of that is being used to provide power.

So for organizations where uptime is critical, manufacturing facilities and more recently data centers (Apple, eBay), the prospect of creating a microgrid to generate reliable megawatts is enticing. Add to this the fact that consumers are now self generating more than 5 gigawatts a year through onsite generation like rooftops solar, and the reality is setting in that utilities no longer will control all of the power generation on the grid.

A role for the utilities?

Pullins noted of the trend toward off the grid energy generation that “one of the concerns from the utility side of the meter is reduced revenue.” He added “you’re not going to prevent consumers from self generating. How do you become part of that bandwagon?”

We’ve seen the discomfort from utilities in the recent net metering controversy in California where the state decided to allow customers with distributed solar installation to sell excess electricity back to the grid. The utilities argued that they were responsible for maintaining the grid and they now were losing revenue.

But some utilities are experimenting. Forward looking San Diego Gas & Electric is testing a 5 megawatt Borrego Springs utility distribution microgrid project. San Diego has a high penetration of solar PV in its service territory and it has a thousand diverse load customers participating in the trial. The more distributed renewable energy a utility has, the more a microgrid starts to make sense since you have a mix of generators and consumers in your system. The project includes energy storage as well as distributed automation capabilities.

Pullins was also getting at a larger question. If distributed renewable power generation is inevitable, is getting cheaper, and is getting more attractive to not just residents but large companies, what role could the utilities play?

The pitch to utilities is as the role of partner for its big rate paying customers and aiding them in their deployment of microgrids. The argument includes the fact that capital asset utilization rates are higher on microgrids because of greater thermal efficiencies, which translates into needing less actual power generating capacity to meet the needs of customers.

Microgrids also allow the tailoring of generation mix with the needs of customers, meaning it’s possible to align the attributes of a power generation technology like solar or fuel cells with the specific demands of a customer, including the amount of power it needs and when it needs it.  What this is driving at is the elimination (or reduction) of demand response payments because you need less overall energy capacity.

Pike Research has forecast that the global remote microgrid market will expand from 349 megawatts to 1.1 gigawatts by 2017, translating into more than $10.2 billion in revenue by 2017. There’s a clear trajectory of growth for the market though a lot of this is slated for the developing world. But as renewable energy allows consumers to take increasing control over their power generation, might the utilities want to step in and actively develop their own microgrids to meet the needs of their customers?




Question of the week

How optimistic are you about microgrid development in the developed world?

Controversial clean power line is finally live

It was a project that took five years to fight off critics and secure regulatory permits. But now the Sunrise Powerlink — a transmission line to ferry clean power like solar and wind from California’s desert to its southern coastal region — is done and live.

Utilities embrace Green Button energy data project

Nine more utilities, and three large energy vendors, announced support on Thursday for the Green Button project, which enables utility customers to download their energy consumption data with a click of a button and also use that data for energy-saving apps.

The pressure to add clean power in California

The race for more clean power has intensified in California, and utilities such as PG&E and San Diego Gas & Electric have been busy inking contracts to meet what is the toughest standard in the country.

California utilities lay out smart grid roadmaps

Last week saw California’s big three utilities release in-depth smart grid deployment roadmaps, giving smart grid companies about the closest thing to a detailed plan of attack that they could ask for.

Opportunities in California’s smart grid deployment plans

Last week, California’s big three utilities — Pacific Gas & Electric, Southern California Edison and San Diego Gas & Electric — released in-depth smart grid deployment roadmaps that include about $5.6 billion in smart grid spending over the coming decade. For smart grid companies, it’s about the closest thing to a detailed plan of attack one could ask for. Of course, much of that money is tied up in ongoing smart meter deployments, and another huge chunk is for transmission and distribution grid projects with a limited range of potential competitors. Still, that leaves plenty of opportunities for nimble companies with key software, networking or hardware technologies to fill the gaps that remain. Here are some of them.

Today in Cleantech

California’s big utilities are getting more specific about their smart grid plans. Today is the deadline for Pacific Gas & Electric, Southern California Edison and San Diego Gas & Electric to turn in documents describing just what they want to do on the smart grid front between now and 2020, complete with estimates of the 10-year capital investment plans and costs to be borne by their customers, as well as what they payback will be. PG&E filed its 280-page plan yesterday, and the plans are big — $800 million to $1.25 billion in capital investments and $500 million to $700 million in operating costs over the next 10 years. Of course, that’s meant to deliver $900 million to $2 billion in lower energy purchasing costs, avoided costs of not having to build new power plans, grid reliability improvements and the like. SDG&E’s plan, filed June 6 (PDF), sets a 2006-2020 smart grid cost of $3.6 billion, with a resulting benefit of  $3.8 to $7.1 billion, including a potential “societal and environmental” benefit of as much as $1.9 billion ascribed in part to the advanced grid systems that will let it incorporate the 33-percent intermittent, renewable energy generation that state mandates require it and other major state utilities to have in their power mix by 2020. No doubt the smart grid industry is looking carefully at these cutting-edge utilities to see how the new plans change the expected flow of investment to various technologies. Will smart meters see a diminished emphasis? Will distribution automation, renewable energy integration or energy storage see a big uptick in spending? I’ll be reading the full reports over the weekend to let you know what they say — stay tuned.

Today in Cleantech

Ontario, Canada has what’s arguably the fastest-moving effort in the world to link up smart meters, time-of-use pricing and residential customers — and that means it’s had to deal with issues of energy data privacy longer than most. Dr. Ann Cavoukian, Ontario privacy commissioner, is speaking at eMeter’s smart energy leadership conference in San Francisco this morning to lay out just how Ontario’s “Privacy by Design” system might help other states and regions — like California — handle the issue of privacy. Indeed, Cavoukian said that San Diego Gas & Electric would partner with her office to instill Privacy by Design into its new variable pricing program — a first for California. PbD is too complex to get into here, but Cavoukian stressed the need for a “user-centric” approach to put transparency and accountability terms clearly in front of customers. She also warned that aggregate data, stripped of personal identifiers, can be used in all kinds of data mining and analysis operations — but that “you have to think clearly about what that involves, and whether it can be tracked back to an individual user.” Companies like Google, Microsoft, Intel, HP, Cisco, Schneider Electric and eMeter — and startups like Tendril, EnergyHub, Control4, Onzo, AlertMe, OpenPeak and many more — all want to get access to smart meter data and utility “backhaul” data to deliver energy management and automation services to homeowners. But that data also needs to be protected to avoid abuse, from unwanted data mining for marketing purposes to warrantless surveillance by law enforcement agencies. Just how the data is collected, who “owns” it, and how it’s managed are all tricky questions — and regulations are only starting to catch up to technology on this front. Stay tuned for more — I’m doing a report on California’s new proposed energy data privacy ruling (PDF), and welcome comments on your opinion.

California Lays Out Smart Meter Privacy Rules

California’s utility regulator has proposed rules on how home energy devices should protect smart meter data privacy — and whether the device is “locked” into one company’s platform or technology or not will be a big deal.